Tried + True: Homemade Salt Water Taffy

tried-and-true-salt-water-taffy-2If playing with a wad of hot sticky bubblegum for 15 minutes sounds like fun, then have I got the project for you today! I’m kidding…kind of.

This past Saturday my daughter and I decided to try to make salt water taffy for the first time. I read through a bunch of recipes online, and one thing became immediately clear; making taffy is hard work and sticky…very very sticky! But I wasn’t going to be so easily scared off. I finally settled on a recipe (which we then adapted) from Cupcake Project. I chose her recipe, because she did a great job photographing the steps, I like the fact that her recipe calls for a lower final temperature (since I read on several blogs that their taffy turned out far too hard after using a higher final temperature), and lastly, because she said that the whole project could be done in an hour. That’s my kind of recipe!

For our adaptation, we used 1/2 teaspoon raspberry flavoring (we found it at Michael’s craft store) and 4 drops of blue food coloring; instead of the vanilla bean paste and candy sprinkles in her version. Once cooked to the correct temperature, we patiently waited for the candy to cool just enough so that we wouldn’t scald ourselves (we couldn’t stand to wait any longer than that), we then buttered our hands up, split the candy in two, and each started to taffy pull.


Right away I had problems with the taffy staying together. I think I might have had too much butter on my hands. But then when the butter wore off of my fingers the taffy stuck to my skin…and I mean really truly stuck to them. It was nearly impossible to remove. For some reason my daughter didn’t have the same issue. While I was getting frustrated with my portion, and in a near panic trying to remove the glob of candy from my fingers without losing a layer of skin, she was quickly turning her piece into a beautiful bit of candy magic.

In the end we determined that my hands were much warmer than hers, and this might have been the cause of the overly sticky situation. At one point I started working with my hands over the air conditioning vent, and that seemed to help quite a bit. Unfortunately my arthritic joints eventually gave out, so my daughter stepped in and finished pulling the rest of mine for me, while I wrapped the cut pieces of taffy in parchment paper.

tried-and-true-salt-water-taffy-3They say that all is well that ends well, and in this case that is most definitely true! Even though my particular batch was stubborn, my daughter managed to salvage it, and we had a great memory making experience. Oh…and the finished candy turned out deliciously too! A winner in my book! Find the original recipe we used right here. Just prepare yourself ahead of time for a thorough arm workout!

Photos taken with iPhone 5c

More Food / Recipes, Recipes & Food posts 8 Comments

Creamy Roasted Tomato + Red Bell Pepper Soup

Apple Crisp (and a little printable freebie)
fruit berry cobbler
Good Taste: In Season Fruit or Berry Crumble

Site for Sore Eyes: Roost


  1. Stef / / Reply

    Sorry you had problems, but glad it turned out well in the end! It looks so pretty! Interesting about the hand temperature. I am always cold. I wonder if that made a difference.

    • Ez
      Ez / / Reply

      Thanks for the great recipe Stef! Despite the challenges, my daughter and I still had a load of fun, and the taffy is delicious! Thanks again!

    • Ez
      Ez / / Reply

      It’s not so much tough to make, as it is a thorough workout! ;-) The experience alone was worth it to me though…the candy at the end is just a sweet added bonus. You should try to make a batch sometime soon. I’d love to hear what you think!

  2. Ann Martin / / Reply

    All’s well that ends well! It looks wonderful. So interesting about hand temperature making a big difference… one of those little things we don’t find out until we try!

  3. Nan / / Reply

    You are an amazing woman. The idea of having to keep pulling at it did not appeal to me. I am glad you made it.

  4. Pingback: Welcome To The Weekend - Elizabeth Anne Designs: The Wedding Blog

  5. Pingback: End O' The Week | The Proper Pinwheel

Leave a Comment*



*Hello friend! Your voice is welcomed here! Comments, love notes, and constructive feedback are always heartily appreciated. We are passionate about creating a space that is supportive and inspiring, and reserve the right to remove any mean-spirited or overly self-promotional comments posted. Thank you for helping us create a beautiful online space! xo Ez & the Creature Comforts team

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>